hand reaching into plate full of red velvet cookie dough bites with cupcake nearby and Doughp's cookie dough drops bag behind

Valentine's Gifts

This month all club subscriptions get our exclusive chocolate-dipped strawberry flavor, Date Night!

Filter
Availability
Price
$
-
$
Generic Flavor Description
Sort By
FeaturedBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Looking for something else?
See All
You Jelly? You Jelly? You Jelly? You Jelly? You Jelly?
You Jelly?
Cold Brew Crew Cold Brew Crew Cold Brew Crew Cold Brew Crew
Cold Brew Crew
Ride or Die Ride or Die Ride or Die Ride or Die
Ride or Die
Cookie Monsta Cookie Monsta Cookie Monsta Cookie Monsta
Cookie Monsta
Dunk On 'Em Dunk On 'Em Dunk On 'Em
Dunk On 'Em
Peanut Butter Kiss Peanut Butter Kiss Peanut Butter Kiss
Peanut Butter Kiss
Blondie Blondie Blondie Blondie
Blondie
Brownie Beast Brownie Beast Brownie Beast Brownie Beast
Brownie Beast
Cinnamood Cinnamood Cinnamood Cinnamood
Cinnamood
Fairy Dust Fairy Dust Fairy Dust Fairy Dust
Fairy Dust
You Want S'more!? You Want S'more!? You Want S'more!? You Want S'more!?
You Want S'more!?
Mystery Cup Mystery Cup Mystery Cup Mystery Cup
Mystery Cup
Strawberry Cheesin' Strawberry Cheesin' Strawberry Cheesin' Strawberry Cheesin'
Sold out
Strawberry Cheesin'
Sold Out
Feeling Lucky? Feeling Lucky? Feeling Lucky? Feeling Lucky?
Sold out
Feeling Lucky?
Sold Out
PB Pretzel Crunch PB Pretzel Crunch PB Pretzel Crunch PB Pretzel Crunch
Sold out
PB Pretzel Crunch
Sold Out